The Heresy of I Kissed Dating Goodbye and the Downfall of Its Author

 The Heresy of I Kissed Dating Goodbye and the Downfall of Its Author

Introduction

In the late 1990s, I Kissed Dating Goodbye by Joshua Harris became a cultural phenomenon in evangelical circles. The book, which condemned dating in favor of a strict courtship model, was heralded as biblical wisdom. However, in the years since its release, the teachings of I Kissed Dating Goodbye have been widely discredited, and Harris himself has renounced both the book and his faith. This article explores the heresy behind the purity culture movement, the harm caused by Harris’s teachings, and how his eventual rejection of Christianity exposed the flaws of his ideology.

The Problematic Teachings of I Kissed Dating Goodbye

Harris’s book promoted the idea that dating was inherently sinful and that Christians should only pursue relationships within a highly structured courtship model. Some of the major issues with his teachings include:

  1. Legalism Disguised as Holiness – Harris imposed extra-biblical rules that went beyond Scripture, turning personal conviction into universal doctrine (Colossians 2:20-23).
  2. Shame-Based Purity Culture – The book contributed to a toxic purity culture that left many feeling guilty and broken for having natural desires (Romans 8:1).
  3. Idolizing Marriage Over Christ – Harris suggested that finding a spouse was a reward for holiness, making marriage the ultimate goal rather than a reflection of God's design (1 Corinthians 7:7-9).
  4. Misrepresentation of Biblical Relationships – Nowhere in Scripture does the Bible condemn dating, yet Harris presented his views as God’s way, misleading an entire generation (Proverbs 4:7).

The Harmful Effects of I Kissed Dating Goodbye

Harris’s book had long-lasting repercussions for individuals and the church:

  • Fear of Relationships – Many Christians avoided dating altogether, leading to delayed marriages and fear-based relationships.
  • Guilt and Shame – Those who engaged in dating or made mistakes felt unredeemable, despite the Gospel’s message of grace and forgiveness (Ephesians 2:8-9).
  • Unrealistic Expectations – The book falsely promised that strict courtship would result in perfect marriages, leaving many disillusioned when struggles arose.

Joshua Harris: From Legalism to Apostasy

After years of promoting purity culture, Harris began retracting his teachings in 2018, apologizing for the harm he caused. Shortly after, he announced that he had left Christianity altogether and divorced his wife. His rejection of faith revealed that:

  1. His Teachings Were Not Grounded in Biblical Truth – Harris created a works-based system that failed to sustain him when trials came (Galatians 1:6-9).
  2. He Was a False Teacher – By adding rules that Scripture does not teach, he led many into spiritual bondage rather than freedom in Christ (2 Peter 2:1).
  3. Legalism Fails to Produce True Faith – Harris’s own life proved that outward morality cannot sustain a relationship with God (Matthew 7:22-23).

The Biblical Response to Dating and Relationships

Rather than following the false teachings of purity culture, Christians should look to Scripture’s true guidance on relationships:

  • Dating is Not Sinful – As long as it is done with wisdom, purity, and intentionality, dating can honor God (1 Corinthians 10:31).
  • Grace Over Legalism – No set of man-made rules can replace the Gospel’s message of grace (Romans 6:14).
  • Marriage is a Reflection of Christ, Not a Reward for Purity – Our faithfulness to God is about loving Him first, not about earning a spouse (Matthew 22:37-39).

Conclusion

The teachings of I Kissed Dating Goodbye were a heretical distortion of biblical relationships, rooted in legalism and fear rather than grace and truth. Harris’s own departure from faith confirms that his system was flawed from the start. Instead of embracing man-made purity culture, Christians should pursue Christ-centered relationships that reflect His love, mercy, and wisdom.

The lesson here is clear: When we elevate human rules above God’s Word, we set ourselves up for failure. True faith is found in Christ alone—not in legalistic teachings that promise what only God can fulfill.

Dr. Aaron Corley, D.C.
📞 941-539-3412

For more insights on faith, relationships, and biblical truth, feel free to reach out or follow for more discussions on Christ-centered living.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Chiropractors education

  What a Chiropractic Education Consists Of Chiropractic education is a rigorous and comprehensive journey that prepares individuals to become skilled and knowledgeable chiropractors. Chiropractors are healthcare professionals who focus on diagnosing and treating neuromuscular disorders, primarily through manual adjustments and spinal manipulations. Their education involves extensive coursework, hands-on clinical training, and licensing examinations to ensure competency in providing holistic, non-invasive care to patients. This article outlines the educational path required to become a Doctor of Chiropractic (D.C.), including prerequisite education, chiropractic school curriculum, clinical training, and licensure requirements. Prerequisite Education Before entering chiropractic school, aspiring chiropractors must complete undergraduate coursework. Most chiropractic programs require at least 90 semester hours of college education , though many students earn a bachelor’s degree b...
Read more

Marijuana and FMCSA Rules

  Marijuana and FMCSA Rules By Aaron Corley, D.C., 941-539-3412 The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) enforces stringent drug testing regulations under 49 CFR Parts 382 and 40 to ensure safety in the transportation industry. Despite increasing state-level legalization of marijuana, FMCSA maintains a zero-tolerance policy for its use among commercial motor vehicle (CMV) drivers, reflecting the Department of Transportation’s (DOT) stance that marijuana remains a Schedule I controlled substance under federal law. This creates significant implications for drivers, employers, and the industry. FMCSA mandates drug testing for CMV drivers in pre-employment, post-accident, random, reasonable suspicion, return-to-duty, and follow-up scenarios. A positive marijuana test—defined as THC levels at or above 50 ng/mL (initial test) or 15 ng/mL (confirmatory test)—results in an automatic failure. Consequences include immediate removal from safety-sensitive duties, a “prohibited” ...
Read more

Lose 30 lbs as a Truck Driver

Lose 30 lbs as a Truck Driver By Aaron Corley, DC Truck drivers are the lifeblood of our economy. But life on the road often means long hours sitting, greasy truck stop meals, and little time for exercise. I’ve met hundreds of drivers who feel stuck—physically and mentally—when it comes to their health. If that’s you, I’ve got good news: you can lose 30 pounds , and you don’t need a fancy gym or some magic diet. All you need is a simple plan, a little commitment, and a few tools to work with your lifestyle, not against it. As a chiropractor who works with DOT drivers daily, here’s what I recommend: 1. Cut the Sugar & Liquid Calories The number one enemy? Sugary drinks. That includes sodas, energy drinks, sweet tea, and even those "healthy" fruit juices. Goal: Cut out 1 soda or energy drink per day. Replace it with water or unsweetened iced tea. Result: This one change can drop 10–15 pounds over several months—without doing anything else. 2. Pack High-Protei...
Read more